Historic preservation, which began gaining widespread recognition in the 20th century, has become the cornerstone of many architectural projects. Although this practice originated in the mid-19th century, recent years have seen growing calls to move beyond the traditional ‘adversarial model’ between developers and communities (James Sanders Studio). Today, instead of renovating spaces in stark contrast to their surroundings, there is a heightened emphasis on seamlessly blending buildings into the existing streetscape. This integration is now regarded as an essential principle of historic preservation.
One striking embodiment of this philosophy is the Mercer Hotel in Soho, New York, a building that masterfully balances its storied past with modern design sensibilities. Originally constructed in 1888, this Romanesque Revival landmark was commissioned by Jacob Astor III and designed by architect William Schickel. Over the years, it has served various purposes—housing shops and offices, including fur-trimming businesses. By the late-20th century, the building’s lower three floors had been repurposed to accommodate light manufacturing work and the rest of the building remained derelict.
Ironically, this history complicated the original plans to transform the building. As reported by The New York Times in 1992, developers André Balazs and Campion Platt faced significant challenges reconciling their vision of an elegant hotel with the reality of a factory occupying the lower levels (Lopate). Working with architect James Sanders and designer Lee Jablin, it was ultimately decided that a complete restoration was necessary—one that could justify the potential disruption to the surrounding neighbourhood.
In fact, the neighbourhood became an invaluable resource for the architectural team. Unlike many developments of the 1980s and 1990s, which often prioritised flashy, modern finishes over preserving historic character, the Mercer Hotel was envisioned as a tribute to Soho—honouring both the community’s needs and its rich artistic history. Engaging in conversations with local residents, the team chose to incorporate a pharmacy and florist as the primary retail spaces, a decision that, as The New York Times noted, helped ease tensions between the developers and the community (Lopate).
The design of the Mercer Hotel, both inside and out, further reflected the team’s commitment to preserving the neighbourhood’s charm. Thoughtful details, such as glass light covers on the surrounding sidewalks—originally designed to illuminate underground spaces—along with exposed brick walls and hardwood floors, created a seamless blend of historical authenticity and contemporary elegance. The result is a masterclass in historic preservation that celebrates both the building’s legacy and the community it serves.
Today, the Mercer Hotel remains deeply connected to its artistic roots. It was the birthplace of Watch the Throne, the iconic collaborative album by Jay-Z and Kanye West, during which the duo and their teams occupied six of the hotel’s rooms for several months. The hotel has also hosted other influential figures such as Virgil Abloh, the founder of Off-White, who frequently used the ‘quasi-library’ lobby as his makeshift office during his visits to New York (Yeon Moon). Even rapper A$AP Rocky has paid homage to the hotel’s legacy with his whiskey brand, Mercer and Prince, named after the legendary street. As such, the Mercer continues to be a creative haven, shaping the cultural landscape of New York and beyond.
The Mercer Hotel stands as a remarkable example of how historic preservation can seamlessly merge the past with the present. Through careful restoration and a commitment to honouring both the building’s history and surrounding community, the hotel has not only retained its architectural significance but also become a vibrant part of Soho’s cultural fabric. Its continued influence on art, fashion, and music demonstrates the enduring power of spaces that respect their roots while embracing innovation. As both a preserved landmark and a contemporary hub for creativity, the Mercer Hotel remains a symbol of New York’s ever-evolving identity, proving that the preservation of history can inspire new generations of visionaries.
*Credits